Harnesses VS Collars, Which is Better?

When choosing between a harness and a collar for your dog, it can be challenging to determine which option is best.

Each has its unique advantages, but understanding the benefits of both can help you make an informed decision that prioritises your dog’s comfort, safety and well-being.

Deciding between the two can be overwhelming, so let’s break down the benefits of both harnesses and collars to help you choose the best option. Remember, every dog is different, and it’s certainly not a one-size-fits-all decision. 

At Bark Boutique, we have our fabulous in-house models, Levi and Poppy, each with completely different needs when it comes to selecting either a harness or a collar. 

Let’s explore the benefits of both options to provide some guidance, just like we did for Levi and Poppy.

Harness Benefits

Enhanced Control and Security 

Harnesses provide superior control during walks, making them ideal for training and managing stronger, more energetic dogs. Their secure fit minimises the risk of your dog slipping out and running off, offering peace of mind and safety.

Reduced Strain 

By distributing pressure evenly across your dog’s chest and shoulders, harnesses alleviate strain on the neck. This is beneficial for dogs prone to respiratory issues or those with smaller delicate necks, such as small breeds and brachycephalic breeds such as bulldogs.

Increased Safety for Puppies

Harnesses are a safer option for puppies with developing bones and delicate necks. They help to protect young dogs from injury while they learn to walk on a lead, providing a gentler and more supportive experience during their early developmental stages.

Enhanced Comfort 

Despite the best of training, some dogs will always pull on their leads. Harnesses ensure walks are more comfortable and enjoyable for both the dog and the owner by distributing pressure evenly. This helps to prevent discomfort and reduces the risk of potential injury, making walking adventures pleasant for everyone.

Better Control for Various Activities 

Harnesses are often the preferred choice for activities like running, hiking, and biking with your dog. They offer precise control and enhanced support, increasing safety and comfort for both you and your dog during these activities.

Collar Benefits

Efficient Identification 

Collars excel in holding identification tags, ensuring they are easy visible and accessible in case your dog gets lost. This feature provides peace of mind for dog owners, knowing their dog’s crucial information is readily available.

Simplicity and Convenience 

Collars offer a straightforward and convenient solution for everyday use, particularly at home. Their simple design allows for easy application and removal, making them hassle free for both owners and their dogs. Collars can be comfortably worn throughout the day, ensuring your dog’s ease and freedom of movement.

Effective Training Aid

Collars serve as practical training aids for teaching obedience commands like heel and sit. They provide a straightforward means of communication and control, establishing a direct physical connection between you and your dog. This connection facilitates immediate feedback and corrections, effectively guiding your dog’s behaviour.

Ideal for Calm Walkers

For dogs who walk calmly on a lead, collars offer an effective and comfortable option. Easy lead attachment and detachment makes walks hassle free for both you and your dog, enhancing the overall walking experience.

Wide Variety of Styles 

Collars come in a wide range of styles, designs and materials, allowing you to express your dog’s personality and style while prioritising comfort. With an assortment of options available, there’s a collar to suit every dog’s needs and individuality, ensuring they look stylish whilst staying comfortable. 


Deciding between a harness and a collar depends on your dog’s unique needs, lifestyle and behaviour. Both options have their merits, and the choice comes down to identifying what suits your individual dog best. Collars offer convenience, easy wear and serve as ideal identification tools, whereas harnesses provide enhanced control, safety and comfort, particularly for young or energetic dogs.

At Bark Boutique, we understand the importance of having both collars and harnesses for dogs like Levi and Poppy. This versatility allows us to select the most suitable option for different situations. 

For instance, a forest walk might necessitate harnesses for added control, while a quiet local walk finds Levi and Poppy calm and comfortable in their collars. 

Ultimately, prioritising your dog’s comfort, welfare and safety is paramount when making the collar versus harness decision. 

Choose what works best for you and your dog’s needs.

More Posts